4.5 Stars. What a great story from beginning to end and what an ending. I never saw that coming! Just when you think everything is tied up nice and sweet, the author throws an ending in that stunned me. Both the main characters and the secondary characters are great. Laurel Heights is definitely a different place to live. Scott and Will are both lovable and frustrating at times when they are both denying so much, but there are alot of sweet and tender moments. The whodunit, I thought was well done and had me guessing until the end which does not often happen in books. I hope that there may be a sequel - there needs to be a sequel with this ending.